Vote For The Best Craft Beer Of 2009

It’s been a wonderful journey this year with tons of great craft beer from all over the country. We have listed 40 craft beers that were available in bottle starting 2009, and we’d like you to pick the best one.  This should be a close one, with so many stellar brews to pick from.

YOU CAN WRITE IN A VOTE for a beer not listed. Voting ends January 22nd at 8PM Eastern Time. Please have fun and please no cheating.

Best Craft Beer of 2009

  • Saint Arnold DR 9 (20%, 683 Votes)
  • Victory Yakima Twilight (18%, 623 Votes)
  • Stone/Maui/Ken Schmidt/Aloha Plenty (5%, 183 Votes)
  • Heavy Seas DIPA (5%, 176 Votes)
  • Deschutes Black Butte XXI (5%, 161 Votes)
  • Full Sail Session Black (4%, 128 Votes)
  • SweetWater Dank Tank Big Ol Belgian Blue Balls (3%, 117 Votes)
  • Cigar City 110k +OT Batch 2 - I.R.I.S. (3%, 116 Votes)
  • Lagunitas Little Sumpin' Extra Ale (3%, 99 Votes)
  • Russian River Consecration (3%, 97 Votes)
  • The Bruery Black Tuesday (3%, 88 Votes)
  • 21st Amendment Monk's Blood (2%, 82 Votes)
  • Terrapin Side Project Monks Revenge Double IPA (2%, 72 Votes)
  • Avery duganA IPA (2%, 69 Votes)
  • Lost Abbey Duck Duck Gooze (2%, 59 Votes)
  • Odell Woodcut No. 3 (2%, 58 Votes)
  • Iron Hill Honey Do Wit (2%, 55 Votes)
  • Dogfish Head Sahtea (1%, 49 Votes)
  • Flying Fish Exit 1 Bayshore Oyster Stout (1%, 47 Votes)
  • Great Divide 15th Anniversary Oak Aged IIPA (1%, 44 Votes)
  • Troegs Flying Mouflan (1%, 44 Votes)
  • Sierra Nevada Kellerweis (1%, 43 Votes)
  • Southern Tier Iniquity Black IPA (1%, 40 Votes)
  • Oskar Blues Mama's Little Yella Pils (1%, 35 Votes)
  • Alaskan White Ale (1%, 34 Votes)
  • Firestone Walker 13 (1%, 33 Votes)
  • BrewDog Tactical Nuclear Penguin (1%, 20 Votes)
  • Grand Teton Pursuit of Hoppiness (1%, 18 Votes)
  • DeProef Van TWee Collaboration with Bells (0%, 17 Votes)
  • Allagash Gargamel (0%, 17 Votes)
  • Boulevard Harvest Dance Wheat Wine (0%, 16 Votes)
  • Samuel Adams Long Shot Double IPA (0%, 13 Votes)
  • Karl Strauss Tower 10 IPA (0%, 13 Votes)
  • Port Brewing Hot Rocks Lager (0%, 12 Votes)
  • Ballast Point Brandy Barrel Aged Navigator (0%, 12 Votes)
  • Nectar Ales Black Xantus (0%, 10 Votes)
  • Otter Creek Quercus Vittis Humulus (0%, 7 Votes)
  • Green Flash Fizzy Yellow Beer (0%, 7 Votes)
  • Bootlegger's Mint Chocolate Porter (0%, 6 Votes)
  • Midnight Sun Big Slick (0%, 2 Votes)

Total Voters: 3,405

Loading ... Loading ...


  1. says

    The best I had in ’09 was Pugsley’s Signature Series Smashed Pumpkin, from Shipyard Brewing Company. I waited a long time for it, and it was well worth the wait. I stocked up before it went away. But no doubt it will be back next year.

  2. says

    One of the most interesting in 2009 was Bruery Berliner Weisse and Terrepin & Left Hand Coffee Milk Stout.. but a pretty comprehensive list though. Some though I think shouldn’t be on there, but every has their own ‘Best’ and everyone is right.

  3. Brandon says

    Hair of the Dog Matt and Bourbon Fred from the Wood were beyond anything I’ve experienced last year. I’ll go with Matt since Bourbon Fred hasn’t been bottled yet. Concsecration is up there but not quite on the same level.

  4. Mike says

    The comment from Don would be a good write in vote. I agree that Southern Tier’s Iniquity Black Ale is one of the best, or at least should be on the list. I second Iniquity.

  5. Ben C. says

    Deschutes Red Chair IPA! It was delicious and although I am sad to see my favorite brew “Cinder Cone” leaving their seasonal rotation the induction of a NWPA (Northwest Pale Ale) modeled after the Red Chair has got my taste buds dancing already.

  6. Dennis John Cahill says

    Why has Weyerbacher been excluded from the list..Heresey …or Quad
    OR Blasphemy..or Insanity…or Merry Monks….You gotta give the Easton Pa. Brewery its do..they make some really BIG BEERS and what is the Dogfish Head Beer..I never heard of it or tasted it..hint

  7. Jeremy Pate says

    Cigar City Brewing should be included in this vote, they have some of the most incredible beers I have ever tasted. I nominate the Jai Alai IPA aged on Cedar.

  8. Bill says

    I’ve had some of these, including DR9, and DR9 is not in the same ballpark as Consecration or Duck Duck Gooze. Saint Arnold has the link to the poll on their Facebook page and are encouraging people to vote, so they are getting a lot of votes for their brew. Most of their followers have never tasted anything on this voting list, other than DR9.

    My choice was Duck Duck Gooze, btw.

  9. Al says

    What? No Papago Brewing Elsies, Coconut Joe or Oude Zuipers, any of which could be included in this list.

  10. says

    I think Odell Bourbon Barrel Stout also deserves some recognition. But of the list above I voted for The Lost Abbey Duck Duck Gooze – to die for! Had it at the 2009 GABF – loved it.

  11. Danb says

    Weyerbacher’s Zotten is the best new beer of the year! Can’t believe it was missed. Does this count as my write in vote?

  12. says

    Like many, most of those beers I have never had, nor have any access too. But of all the ones I have had, and of many others not listed…

    Russian Rivers Consecration takes the cake hands down.

  13. Elizabeth B says

    My write in vote is –

    Midnight Project ‘09: Depth Charge by Terrapin and Left Hand Brewing hands down the beer of the year!

  14. says

    After careful consideration, my vote goes to Terrapin Beer Co.’s Side Project #8 Pumpkinfest. While it’s not necessarily a beer I’ll enjoy year round, it was a perfectly-timed one-time release seasonal. Pumpkinfest, in my opinion, is a perfect blend of the pumpkin ale and Oktoberfest varieties. It packs more pumpkin than many other pumpkins, which only rely on pumpkin spice for flavor. At the same time, it’s not as heavy and thick in mouthfeel as a lot of other autumn seasonal thanks to the Oktoberfest half of its split personality, which provides a malty sweetness to complement the pumpkin. Not only did it debut in 2009, but it was only available in 2009, making it the perfect nominee for Best Craft Beer of 2009.

  15. says

    I’d like to know just how many potential voters in this poll can honestly claim to have sampled even one-third of these beers. I refuse to vote because of these beers, I’ve had perhaps ten or fifteen, and maybe only half of those have I had any more than a sip at best. And I live in a particularly beer-rich city. Most of these beers are unobtainable to huge swaths of the American public. So all we’re really looking at here is a popularity contest, high-school-election-for-homecoming-queen style. For gawd’s sake, almost NO ONE in either the States or the UK can claim to have tasted Tactical Nuclear Penguin!

  16. Chumlee says

    Deschutes loaning out the name Twilight name Shows true comitment to the anti-hansen name protection band wagon all the small brewerers were on.

  17. Curt Dawsey says

    Midnight Project ’09: Depth Charge by Terrapin and Left Hand Brewing. Terrapin’s winter seasonal is Wake and Bake, an incredible coffee oatmeal imperial stout. Left Hand’s Milk Stout is absolutely fabulous. They conceptually blended the two to make an espresso milk stout. Perfect. Fantastic. Incredible. Etc. Perhaps the best beer I’ve ever had. I’ve got 7 bottles left, and there is no more to be found. 7 moments of joy, then loss and happy memories.

  18. Julia says

    I’d vote for The Abyss from Deschutes if it was on the list – best beer I’ve had this year! – but their Black Butte XXI was darn good too, so that got my vote.

  19. says

    The best beer that I drank this year was “Babushka’s Secret” an Imperial Stout by Widmer Brewing, which is only served on tap at the company’s Gasthaus Pub in Portland, Oregon. Simply perfect in every possible way.

  20. Keith says

    Only 176 people have voted? We need to get the word out, whoever “we” are. I voted for Karl Strauss Tower 10 IPA as it was the only beer on the list I’ve had and I really do like it. Wish it was sold at Costco by the case. However, the Ballast Point Brewery is within walking distance of my house and I could just walk there and try there beer.

Leave a Reply